My take:
In my opinion, the story in this was a bit lacking. It felt a bit too cliche and the ending was a bit too close to Shadow of the Colossus. Yes I know this is a tribute, but I the ending honestly did not do it for me.
As far as game play goes, this game is a solid A. Fantastic adaptation of Shadow of the Colossus. It was very fun to play and I found the third monster quite difficult. However, I do have to agree with others that the jumping is a bit buggy. But, besides that the gameplay was very enjoyable.
The music for the menu, first, and third monster were fantastic, but the music for the cut scenes did not fit. Also, the music for the 2nd monster reminded me of Pokemon, or even Runescape for that matter. It just didn't fit compared to the rest of the tunes.
Anyway, despite the obvious jumping flaws this was a solid and fun game. A bit quick I might add, but fun none the less.
8/10
5/5